The price of a policy can be critical to attain the volume and profitability an MGA needs to grow. This is a field of actuarial science of great importance. Especially in the UK, pricing can be extremely competitive. Specific to MGA’s, several tactics are often used to differentiate their pricing;
- Data Driven Pricing
By utilising data and analytics in a superior manner MGA’s can understand risk better. Price it correctly and consequently select risk with better accuracy, driving underwriting performance. - Niche and Flexible Products
MGA’s are nimble and innovative companies. They can sometimes identify a hole in the market. A tailored product designed for a specific segment of the market. This differentiates the product and can be successful in growing volume profitably. - Strategic Discounts and Bundling
A process of bundling risk differently. Potentially combining risks/coverages that aren’t traditionally combined. The goal is to lower the overall risk premium. This enables additional discounting capabilities and if applied right can be highly successful. - Margin and Lifetime Value Modelling
By utilising data and analytics the MGA tries to better understand the long term profitability of a customer. By understanding this MGA’s can squeeze the margin and potentially attain more business. - Broker Partnerships & Speed
MGA’s can also work with local brokers to develop pricing which is calibrated for them specifically. This makes the quoting more tailored towards specific customers. In addition MGA’s can optimise the responsiveness of the quoting process, giving customer fast and compelling pricing.
Challenges In Scaling Pricing
The challenge in applying these pricing tactics are several, but a key one is scalability. And the topic of scalability is one that focuses on: i)The marginal effort to update pricing strategies. Ii) The time it takes to develop a completely new approach and validate it’s value in the market. iii) And of course the marginal cost of the infrastructure as it grows.
MGA’s will always be a source for entrepreneurship and innovation. And at times those business models are bootstrapped. This means that at the start a group of passionate and ambitious individuals test and validate a business model. During this time it makes absolute sense to use readily available tools that may not be designed for insurance pricing, but can do a meaningful job at getting the core value proposition to the market.
There is however a moment after this initial process where the name of the game is scalability. The goal is to generate volume and from this volume generate a profitable book. Within the goal of scaling the business meets new challenges.
- Growing Market Share
In an effort the grow market share, as pricing actuaries we want to improve the performance of the pricing model. We want to understand claim behaviour and get the technical price right. While allowances are made at the start, at greater volume, getting this understanding right is critical to avoiding a big accident in underwriting performance. Equally in an effort to grow volume, we want to understand where policies convert. Getting this understanding as perfect as possible so we sacrifice the least amount of premium for maximum amount of conversions. - Deployment
Operationalising these tariffs is often the biggest bottleneck. Let’s assume you are using a software house to distribute your products. These companies often have a lead time of 6 weeks to get your tariffs into the market. But before this clock starts you need to test your rates into their setup. And before this you need to configure and decide on where you want your commercial premiums to sit. To make a long story short, it can quickly take between 2 and 3 months to update a price. This presents a challenge because the data/insights that inform these decisions can age quickly. But more importantly, this is a data game. You want to try things, test them, cross reference their effectiveness and recalibrate. Accepting such a long lead time implies acceptance that you don’t have these insights/efficiencies.
Automation Is The Name Of The Game
The name of the game becomes automation. At a certain point you want the cost of growing volume to become incrementally lower. Tooling around pricing can be critical for this. Tools exist that utilise API technology to connect pricing models directly into underwriting systems. However these are complex and expensive because they aim to recalculate and rescore a model for each quote.
MavenBlue has a different idea. The idea is to translate pricing models to machine code i.e. JAVA or even C++ (for older COBOL based systems). This is faster, it can handle more model complexity in real time and critically it is a lot cheaper to run. In other words, scaling these processes has improved a lot.
In addition the benefit of this approach also extends to those that still utilise Excel for pricing. While commercial and specialty lines often don’t have the same modelling complexity of retail, underwriters do want to ensure their process is consistent and controlled well. Automating this process efficiently and cost effectively can be critical to the long term success of an MGA.
Find Out More: https://mgaa.co.uk/members/mavenblue/
We think you also might like …
Regulating for Impact: Why MGAs Take A Leading Role in the Next Phase of AI‑Driven Insurance
By Andy How, Director of Insurance EMEA, Earnix Artificial intelligence (AI) is quickly finding itself at the core of strategic decision‑making for insurance leaders. Whether it’s real‑time pricing, dynamic underwriting, or personalised customer journeys, AI is reshaping how insurance products are developed and distributed, and how insurance is being made more relevant and delivered more...
16th September 2025
Unlocking the Power of Management Information: A Smarter Approach for MGAs
In today’s fast-evolving insurance landscape, Managing General Agents are navigating regulatory scrutiny, economic uncertainty and technological innovation. In response, many are looking to enhance their technical capabilities, improve data integrity and align more closely with strategic goals to stay competitive and resilient. Amid this dynamic backdrop and competing time pressures, the importance of efficiently producing...
16th September 2025
AM Best: MGA Market Growth Reshapes P/C Landscape
MGAA CEO Michael Keating joins the AM Best Audio Podcast to share how Managing General Agents are driving significant change across Property & Casualty (P&C) insurance. In the episode, Mike outlines how MGAs are fuelling industry growth, championing innovation, and cultivating deeper collaboration throughout the insurance ecosystem. We’d like to thank AM Best for allowing...
15th September 2025