Back to News

Outbound: The MGAs Winning the AI Implementation Game Have One Thing in Common: Better Security

Blog

6th August 2025

As you’re reading this, the UK Managing General Agents (MGA) sector stands at a pivotal moment. With private equity investment reaching all-time highs and carriers increasingly viewing MGAs as strategic partners rather than mere distributors, there is more opportunity than ever for agents to expand their capacity.

But increased opportunity also means increased competition. With more MGAs vying for the same deals, traditional differentiators like broker relationships and underwriting experience are no longer enough.

A rising number of agents are turning to artificial intelligence (AI) tools to stand out. So, it might surprise you to hear that “Should we adopt AI too?” is not the question you should be asking.

The better question is why some of your competitors are succeeding with AI while others struggle to implement it effectively – and how to make sure you’re not part of that number.

How Your Competitors Are Using AI

Across the UK market, we’re seeing artificial intelligence create genuine advantages for MGAs.

  • Motor MGAs are using real-time telematics data to offer usage-based policies.
  • Cyber insurance specialists are analysing companies’ cyber security postures in real-time to provide tailored coverage and pricing that reflects actual risk levels. Some are implementing continuous network monitoring to try and protect clients, adjust premiums, and reduce claims.
  • Even the insurance technology platforms that competitors use are moving from workflow-based solutions to AI predictive flows that anticipate market trends and customer needs.
  • Commercial property MGAs are combining satellite imagery, weather data, and building characteristics to assess risks with unprecedented accuracy. AI-powered modelling enables them to forecast faster than traditional methods, too.

Where these were experimental pilot programs five years ago, these production systems are now processing millions of data points to make decisions that traditional small and mid-sized teams simply can’t match for speed and consistency.

Clearly, there’s a lot to be gained from integrating AI-powered tools. However, as these systems become more sophisticated and handle more sensitive data, they’re creating entirely new categories of risk that some MGAs haven’t fully considered – and that’s where they’re going wrong.

The Security-First Mindset That’s Really Giving Them the Edge

Here’s what separates the AI winners from the strugglers: they think about security from day one, not as an afterthought.

While some businesses treat security as something to bolt on after building AI systems, your successful competitors embed it into every aspect of their AI development.

They understand that handling telematics data means becoming a data processor under GDPR. They recognise that analysing company IT infrastructures makes them a target for the same cybercriminals they’re assessing. They know that carriers scrutinise their operational security as closely as their underwriting performance. They’re aware of the shadow AI risks being posed by newer credit card-based solutions that staff might use independently.

This security-first mindset shapes everything they do. When collecting training data, they’re already planning how to demonstrate algorithmic transparency to regulators. When designing AI models, they’re building in explainability features that prove decisions aren’t discriminatory. When deploying tools like Microsoft Copilot, they’re carefully reviewing access permissions to ensure staff won’t be fed information that they should not be privy to.

The difference in outcome is profound. While others struggle with lengthy compliance reviews and carrier due diligence processes, these MGAs move quickly. They’ve already addressed the concerns carriers haven’t even asked about yet.

How Are Top MGAs Ensuring Secure AI Implementation?

Your most successful competitors aren’t doing this alone. They’re working with specialised security partners like Outbound who can provide guidance on securing AI implementations and ensuring compliance, while leaving the AI model development to the MGAs themselves.

These arrangements give businesses access to specialists who can oversee AI governance, validate model security, and ensure ongoing compliance as regulations evolve.

Such partnerships start with comprehensive security assessments that evaluate not just a business’s technology infrastructure but their entire organisational approach to:

  • Data handling
  • Staff training
  • Incident response

This forms the first stage of an ongoing evaluation that will mature as their AI capabilities expand.

Perhaps most importantly, these MGAs are building business continuity plans that account for AI-specific failure modes. They understand that AI-dependent operations require different resilience strategies than traditional underwriting processes.

Why This Approach Wins More Capacity

According to the MGA Opinion Report 2025, 57% of carriers expect their MGA capacity allocation to increase over the next two years. But they’re increasingly selective, looking for MGAs who can demonstrate not just underwriting expertise but operational excellence across the entire risk management spectrum.

When these agents approach carriers for capacity, the conversation is starting to shift. While most carriers haven’t yet incorporated AI security assessments into their standard due diligence processes, the more forward-thinking capacity providers are beginning to ask different questions. They’re interested in data handling protocols, cyber resilience planning, and operational governance – especially when MGAs are using AI systems to process sensitive information.

Security-mature MGAs are setting the bar in this respect, demonstrating capabilities that carriers are increasingly valuing even if they’re not yet formally requiring them. As regulatory scrutiny intensifies and AI adoption accelerates, these MGAs are positioning themselves ahead of what will likely become standard expectations.

Think Your Business Is Too Niche for AI?

Many MGAs, including those in highly specialised trade sectors, still believe their needs are too unique for AI applications. This thinking misses the broader opportunity.

AI can make most manual tasks more efficient, enabling your team to focus on higher-value, strategic-level activities. It can streamline policy administration, automate routine communications, enhance risk assessment processes, and improve claims handling even in the most specialised markets.

The security-first mindset we’ve discussed applies regardless of whether you’re using AI for complex risk modelling or simple operational efficiency. Any business can be successful with AI, provided they approach implementation with a strategy that’s been tailored to them.

The best way to create this strategy? Partner with an experienced technology guide like Outbound.

Now You Know the Secret

Businesses who’ve embraced this approach are achieving more than added capacity. They’re entering markets others can’t access, launching products faster, and building carrier relationships based on trust rather than constant oversight.

They’ve discovered what many others miss: successful AI adoption isn’t just about the technology. It’s about the security mindset that makes carriers trust you with it.

Cyber Resilience in the AI Revolution: Tools to Power Growth and Protect Your Business

Join us on 16 October for Cyber Resilience in the AI Revolution, a half-day event designed specifically for businesses navigating modern-day security challenges. You’ll be guided through the latest threat landscape, the human side of cyber security, and simple steps to help you and your business stay safe.

Register here: https://visit-our.link/gsr5thd

 

Find out more about Outbound Group: Click Here 

We think you also might like …

Insurance Insider: Parametric Solutions in Cyber on the Up as SME Coverage Needs Grow

With companies growing more dependent on digital infrastructure and cloud systems for day-to-day operations, cyber insurers are looking at parametric and agreed value solutions for business interruption (BI) claims, multiple sources in the industry said.

6th August 2025

Blog

DynaRisk: From Reactive to Proactive: How MGAs Can Take Control of Cyber Risk

The insurance industry has long taken a reactive approach to cyber risk, responding to incidents only after they occur. But as cyber threats become more frequent, complex, and costly, this approach is no longer sustainable.

6th August 2025

Blog

MGAA Welcomes FCA’s Simplification Drive but Calls for Broader Reform

The Managing General Agents’ Association (MGAA) has submitted a response to the Financial Conduct Authority’s (FCA) consultation paper CP 25/12 – Simplifying Insurance, welcoming the initiative while calling for broader reforms that reflect the unique role and value of MGAs within the UK insurance market.

1st August 2025

Regulatory & Compliance